Definitely a 5! I have been using this dip for over 15 years. I used to buy it in a shop in California. Now that I live in Texas I order it online and buy 5 at a time. So delicious! I have only eaten it hot. I buy a long loaf of French bread and cut it into chunks. Always for a crowd and it goes fast. I usually make a double batch. You cannot go wrong with this one!